Section 15-16-1
Section 15-16-1 Defense of insanity to be by special plea.
When the defense of insanity is set up in any criminal prosecution, it must be by special plea, interposed at the time of arraignment and entered of record upon the docket of the court, which, in substance, shall be "not guilty by reason of insanity." A plea of insanity shall not preclude the usual plea of the general issue, which shall not, however, put in issue the question of the irresponsibility of the accused by reason of his alleged insanity, this question being triable only under the special plea.
(Code 1896, §4939; Code 1907, §7176; Code 1923, §4573; Code 1940, T. 15, §423.)Section 15-16-2
Section 15-16-2 Presumption of responsibility for acts; burden of proving irresponsibility.
Every person over 14 years of age charged with crime is presumed to be responsible for his acts, and the burden of proving that he is irresponsible is cast upon the accused. The defense of insanity in all criminal prosecutions shall be clearly proved to the reasonable satisfaction of the jury.
(Code 1896, §4938; Code 1907, §7175; Code 1923, §4572; Code 1940, T. 15, §422.)Section 15-16-20
Section 15-16-20 Duty of judge to institute investigation on sanity of certain confined persons; proceedings where person found insane.
If any person other than a minor in confinement, under indictment, for want of bail for good behavior, for keeping the peace or appearing as a witness, in consequence of any summary conviction appears to be insane, the judge of the circuit court of the county where he is confined must institute a careful investigation, call a respectable physician and call other credible witnesses; and, if he deems it necessary, he may call a jury, for which purpose he is empowered to compel attendance of witnesses and jurors. If it is satisfactorily proved that the person is insane, the judge may discharge him from imprisonment and order his safe custody and removal to the Alabama state hospitals, where he must remain until restored to his right mind, and then, if the judge shall have so directed, the superintendent must inform the judge and sheriff, whereupon the person must be remanded to jail and criminal proceedings be resumed, or he must be otherwise discharged.
(Code 1867, §1060; Code 1876, §1488; Code 1886, §4816; Code 1896, §4942; Code 1907, §7180; Code 1923, §4577; Code 1940, T. 15, §428.)Section 15-16-21
Section 15-16-21 Suspension of felony trial to inquire into accused's sanity; proceedings upon jury findings; resumption of proceedings when sanity restored; release restriction.
If any person charged with any felony is held in confinement under indictment and the trial court shall have reasonable ground to doubt his sanity, the trial of such person for such offense shall be suspended until the jury shall inquire into the fact of such sanity, such jury to be impaneled from the regular jurors in attendance for the week or from a special venire, as the court may direct. If the jury shall find the accused sane at the time of its verdict, it shall make no other inquiry, and the trial in chief shall proceed. If it finds that he is insane at that time, the court shall make an order committing him to the Alabama state hospitals, where he must remain until he is restored to his right mind. When the superintendent of the hospitals shall be of opinion that such person is so restored, he shall forthwith, in writing, inform the judge and sheriff of such court of the fact, whereupon such person must be remanded to jail on an order of such judge and the criminal proceedings resumed. In no event shall such a person be set at large so long as such prosecution is pending or so long as he continues to be insane.
(Code 1896, §4941; Code 1907, §7178; Code 1923, §4575; Code 1940, T. 15, §426.)Section 15-16-22
Section 15-16-22 Duty of judge to order examination of defendant in capital cases; observation and examination of defendant by commission on lunacy; report by commission; order of clerk of court; expenses of removal of defendant.
(a) Whenever it shall be made known to the presiding judge of a court by which an indictment has been returned against a defendant for a capital offense, that there is reasonable ground to believe that such defendant may presently lack the capacity to proceed or continue to trial, as defined in Section 22-52-30, or whenever said judge receives notice that the defense of said defendant may proceed on the basis of mental disease or defect as a defense to criminal responsibility; it shall be the duty of the presiding judge to forthwith order that such defendant be committed to the Department of Mental Health and Mental Retardation for examination by one or more mental health professionals appointed by the Commissioner of the Department of Mental Health and Mental Retardation. The commissioner shall place the defendant under the observation and examination of one or more mental health professionals, each of whom is either a licensed psychologist holding a Psy. D. or Ph.D degree or a licensed physician who specializes in psychiatry. The assigned mental health professional(s) shall examine the defendant with respect to determining the presence of any mental disease or defect which, if determined to be present, would affect the capacity of the defendant to proceed or continue to trial or which would affect the defendant's criminal responsibility at the time of the commission of the crime.
(b) Such defendant shall be subject to the observation of and examination by the mental health professional(s) appointed by the commissioner for such length of time as may be necessary to determine the mental condition of the defendant so far as it affects his capacity to proceed or continue to trial or his criminal responsibility.
(c) As soon as the assigned mental health professional(s) has completed the examination of the defendant, said mental health professional(s) shall make a full written report thereof to the clerk of the court in which the indictment against said defendant is pending, which report shall be placed on file and be accessible to the court, to the district attorney and to the counsel for the defendant.
(d) It shall be the duty of the clerk of said court upon receipt of said report to issue an order to the sheriff of the county directing that such defendant be remanded and removed to jail and that the criminal proceedings against him be resumed or he be otherwise legally discharged.
(e) The expense of removing such defendant to and from the hospitals and of maintaining him while there confined shall be paid in the same manner as provided by law in the case of persons adjudged to be of unsound mind following inquisition in the probate court.
(Acts 1933, Ex. Sess., No. 157, p. 144; Code 1940, T. 15, §425; Acts 1990, No. 90-637, p. 1171.)Section 15-16-23
Section 15-16-23 Suspending execution of death sentence of insane convict; order upon restoration to sanity; limitations on jurisdiction to suspend execution.
If after conviction and sentence to death, but at any time before the execution of the sentence, it is made to appear to the satisfaction of the trial court that the convict is then insane, such trial court shall forthwith enter an order in the trial court suspending the execution of the sentence to the time fixed in the order; and, if it subsequently is made to appear to the court that such convict, the execution of the sentence of whom has thus been suspended, is restored to sanity, the trial court shall forthwith have another order entered ordering and commanding the execution of the judgment and sentence originally awarded in said court at a time fixed in such order. This mode of suspending the execution of sentence after conviction on account of the insanity of the convict shall be exclusive and final and shall not be reviewed or revised by or renewed before any other court or judge. No court or judge in this state shall have the power or right to suspend the execution of sentence of any other court of record on account of the insanity of the convict. This section shall not prevent the judge or court from impaneling a jury to try the question of insanity or from examining such witnesses as he may deem proper for guidance.
(Code 1907, §7179; Code 1923, §4576; Code 1940, T. 15, §427.)Section 15-16-24
Section 15-16-24 Special verdict of not guilty due to insanity; general verdict of not guilty or verdict of conviction.
If it shall appear from the evidence that a defendant did the act charged as constituting the offense, but at the time of committing the act he was insane, the jury shall render a special verdict to the effect that the defendant is not guilty by reason of insanity, but if the jury does not believe from the evidence that the defendant committed the act or if it believes from the evidence that he is not guilty upon any ground other than his alleged insanity, it must return a general verdict of not guilty; otherwise, it must return a verdict of conviction.
(Code 1896, §4940; Code 1907, §7177; Code 1923, §4574; Code 1940, T. 15, §424.)Section 15-16-3
Section 15-16-3 Costs of moving prisoners to be defrayed by state; recovery of costs by state.
The costs of removing an insane prisoner to and from the Alabama state hospitals under any of the provisions of this chapter must be defrayed by the state as in the case of removal of prisoners from one county to another; and such cost, together with the expenses of such patient in the hospital, may be recovered by the state from such person, his estate or any relative who would have been bound to provide for and maintain him elsewhere.
(Code 1896, §4945; Code 1907, §7183; Code 1923, §4580; Code 1940, T. 15, §431.)Section 15-16-41
Section 15-16-41 Determination of necessity for hearing as to involuntary commitment of defendant found not guilty by reason of insanity; subsequent proceedings.
If a defendant in a criminal case is found not guilty by reason of insanity, the court shall forthwith determine whether the defendant should be held for a hearing on the issue of his involuntary commitment to the Alabama State Department of Mental Health. If the court determines that there is probable cause to believe that the defendant is mentally ill and as a consequence of such mental illness poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others, the court shall order the defendant into the custody of the sheriff until a hearing can be held to determine whether the defendant shall be involuntarily committed. If the court does not make such a determination, then the defendant shall be forthwith released from custody.
(Acts 1981, No. 81-708, p. 1189, §1.)Section 15-16-42
Section 15-16-42 Final hearing following finding of probable cause.
Whenever the court finds probable cause pursuant to Section 15-16-41, the court shall hold a final hearing within 30 days to determine whether the defendant shall be involuntarily committed.
(Acts 1981, No. 81-708, p. 1189, §2.)Section 15-16-43
Section 15-16-43 Commitment of defendant upon finding of mental illness.
If, at the final hearing, the court finds that the defendant is mentally ill and as a consequence of such mental illness poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others, the court shall order the defendant committed to the custody of the Commissioner of the Alabama State Department of Mental Health or to such other public facility as the court may order.
If the court does not make such a finding, then the defendant shall be released from custody forthwith.
(Acts 1981, No. 81-708, p. 1189, §3.)Section 15-16-60
Section 15-16-60 Short title.
This article shall be entitled "The Criminal Psychopath Release Restriction Act."
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §1.)Section 15-16-61
Section 15-16-61 Definitions.
The following definitions shall apply to this article:
(1) COURT. The court which committed the defendant pursuant to Section 15-16-43.
(2) DEFENDANT. A defendant in a criminal case who has been found not guilty by reason of insanity, or not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect, and has been committed to the custody of the Alabama State Department of Mental Health and Mental Retardation or another facility as provided by Section 15-16-43.
(3) DEPARTMENT. The State Department of Mental Health and Mental Retardation.
(4) DISTRICT ATTORNEY. The district attorney for the judicial circuit of the court which committed the defendant pursuant to Section 15-16-43.
(5) REGIONAL OR COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH FACILITY. Any mental health facility providing mental health services pursuant to Sections 22-51-1 through 22-51-14.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §2.)Section 15-16-62
Section 15-16-62 Defendant not released from custody unless authorized by court order.
When a defendant in a criminal case has been committed to the custody of the commissioner of the department or another facility as provided by Section 15-16-43, such department or facility may not release such defendant from custody unless authorized to do so by court order as provided in this article.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §3.)Section 15-16-63
Section 15-16-63 Department must give notice of opinion that defendant is no longer mentally ill, poses no threat of substantial harm, etc.; inclusion in notice of conditional release plan.
Whenever the department or other facility with custody of a defendant is of the opinion that the defendant is no longer mentally ill, or that the defendant no longer poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others by being at large, or no longer poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others by being at large if certain conditions are imposed upon his release, the department or other facility shall give notice in writing to the court of that opinion. The department or other facility shall contemporaneously send copies of that notice to: the district attorney; the regional or community mental health facility which is or may be involved if the defendant is released; and the defendant, or his guardian, or his attorney. The department may include in such notice a conditional release plan if the department deems such a plan appropriate.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §4.)Section 15-16-64
Section 15-16-64 Date of hearing; notice.
The court shall set a hearing to be held within 30 days of its receipt of the notice described in Section 15-16-63, unless an order of release either with or without conditions is stipulated by the department and all the parties to whom notice is required in Section 15-16-63. The court shall give notice of the date of that hearing to the department and to all the parties to whom notice is required in Section 15-16-63.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §5.)Section 15-16-65
Section 15-16-65 Appointed counsel; payment.
Where the defendant does not have an attorney, the court shall appoint him one for purposes of the hearing. Payment of appointed counsel for indigent defendants shall be at the same rates and with the same limitations as would apply if the hearing were a criminal prosecution.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §6.)Section 15-16-66
Section 15-16-66 Release of defendant upon failure to hold hearing.
If a hearing is not held within 60 days of receipt by the court of the notice described in Section 15-16-63, the defendant shall be released forthwith unless for good cause shown the hearing is continued for a reasonable time.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §7.)Section 15-16-67
Section 15-16-67 Determination as to condition of defendant; disposition of defendant.
If, after conducting the hearing, the court determines that the defendant is no longer mentally ill or no longer poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others by being at large, the court shall order his release. If the court determines that the defendant is still mentally ill but no longer poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others by being at large if his release is accompanied by certain conditions, the court shall order his release subject to those conditions necessary to prevent the defendant from posing a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §8.)Section 15-16-68
Section 15-16-68 Court-imposed conditions for release.
The conditions that the court may impose upon release, if necessary and appropriate, include, the following:
(1) That the defendant take medication as prescribed by doctors in the department or in a regional or community mental health facility, or by some other doctor whose care the defendant is in;
(2) That the defendant submit to treatment and accept care from a duly authorized outpatient facility such as a regional or community mental health facility;
(3) That the defendant submit to mental or medical evaluation or testing as prescribed by the department, by a regional or community mental health facility, or by other appropriate person or facility;
(4) That the defendant submit to periodic or random drug testing designed to ensure that he is taking any prescribed drugs and avoiding any prescribed drugs including alcohol;
(5) That the defendant avoid specified activities, persons, or places that may be detrimental to his condition;
(6) Any other appropriate condition that is necessary to prevent the defendant from posing a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others while he is at large.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §9.)Section 15-16-69
Section 15-16-69 Specific conditions for conditional release must be stated; periodic reports regarding defendant's compliance; periodic reports not deemed violative of doctor-patient privilege.
If conditional release is ordered, the court shall state the specific conditions to be followed by the defendant. The order shall also direct the appropriate agencies or persons to submit periodic reports to the court regarding the defendant's compliance with the conditions of release and progress in treatment, with copies to the district attorney, to the defendant or his guardian or counsel, and to the individual or institution from which the defendant is released. Such reports shall not be deemed to be a violation of any doctor-patient, psychiatrist-patient, or psychologist-patient privilege.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §10.)Section 15-16-70
Section 15-16-70 Modification of release conditions or order to return for further treatment; notice of hearing; standard for modifications and orders.
If at any time it appears that the defendant has failed to comply with the conditions of release, that the defendant's condition has deteriorated to the point that inpatient care is required, or that the release conditions should be modified, the court may, after a hearing, modify the release conditions or order the defendant returned to the Department of Mental Health and Mental Retardation for further treatment. All such hearings shall be preceded by notice to the department and to the parties required to be notified in Section 15-16-63. All such modifications and orders shall be guided by the standard of whether such modifications and orders are necessary to ensure that the defendant does not pose a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §11.)Section 15-16-71
Section 15-16-71 Removal of conditions of release or release without conditions after notice and hearing.
If at any time after a defendant has been conditionally released, it appears that removal of some of the conditions or release of the defendant without conditions will not cause the defendant to pose a real and present threat of substantial harm to himself or to others by being at large, the court, after a hearing, shall remove the unnecessary conditions, or it shall order the defendant released unconditionally and terminate its jurisdiction over the case, as the case may be. All such hearings shall be preceded by notice to the department and to the parties required to be notified in Section 15-16-63.
(Acts 1988, No. 88-581, p. 906, §12.)
|